French Cap, USVI
 
Andy Tobin
Andrew M. Tobin, Trial Counsel

Jim Mattson
James S. Mattson, Appellate Counsel

Sutton v. Monroe County

Sutton v. Monroe County was dismissed December 1, 2008, on Statute of Limitation Grounds, by Circuit Judge Luis Garcia. Ms. Sutton appealed the final judgment to the Florida Third District Court of Appeal (DCA). On December 31, 2008, the 3rd DCA REVERSED Shands v City of Marathon and Collins, et al. v. Monroe County & State of Florida, two appeals of earlier Audlin dismissals on the same statute of limitation theory. The Shands decision was final (mandate issued) on January 15, 2009. The December 31, 2008, Collins decision was the subject of a certiorari petition to the Florida Supreme Court -- that went nowhere.

In light of the Third DCA's Shands and Collins decisions, we filed motions with the Third District Court of Appeal, on February 6, 2009, asking them to remand Beyer, McCole, and Sutton  to the trial court. This motion was denied, and the 3d DCA affirmed Judge Garcia's decision on December 23, 2009.